Welcome to New York New York Pizza Tampa
At New York New York Pizza Tampa, we bring the authentic taste of New York to Florida. Nestled at 533 S Howard Ave, our pizzeria prides itself on hand-tossed pies made from high-quality ingredients, including pure olive oil. Customers rave about our generous toppings, with highlights like the extra-large Meat Lovers pizza and crispy Buffalo wings that keep patrons coming back for more. Beyond pizza, our menu offers tantalizing appetizers like Fried Mozzarella and Jalapeno Poppers. With quick service and a warm atmosphere, New York New York Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving true New York-style pizza in Tampa.
-
533 S Howard Ave, Tampa, FL 33606 Hotline: (813) 253-3929
If you find yourself in Tampa and have a craving for authentic New York-style pizza, look no further than New York New York Pizza Tampa. Located at 533 S Howard Ave, this gem offers a delicious blend of Italian and American cuisine that will transport your taste buds straight to the bustling streets of New York City. A phone call to (813) 253-3929 will have you one step closer to enjoying their mouthwatering offerings.
One of the standout features of New York New York Pizza is its commitment to quality. Many customers rave about the freshness of the ingredients and the care put into each dish. As Flor R. noted in her review, the use of olive oil and high-quality products makes a significant difference in taste. The dough is made by hand and only the best is kept for sale—any unsold pies are tossed at the end of the day, ensuring that what's on your plate is always fresh and delightful.
The menu at New York New York Pizza Tampa is a testament to classic favorites and hearty portions. Whether you opt for their famous Buffalo Wings or a comforting Caesar Salad, you won't be disappointed. But let’s not forget their range of mouthwatering pizzas. Patrons like Jeremy G. commend their love for the meat lovers pizza, generously topped, ensuring every bite is satisfying. The crust is another highlight, praised for its authenticity and texture, making each slice a culinary joy.
For appetizers, you can’t miss the tempting Cheese Manhattan Rolls and Garlic Knots, perfect complements to your pizza. The fried zucchini sticks and mac and cheese bites are also popular, showcasing variety that is appealing to all types of diners. Even if pizza isn't your go-to, as Rosa H. mentioned, the garlic knots alone are worth the visit.
Dining at New York New York Pizza not only satisfies your hunger but also brings a warmth that feels like home. With convenient take-out options and a couple of outdoor tables, it's ideal for a quick lunch or a laid-back evening out with friends and family. So, whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, make sure to stop in and taste what many are calling the best pizza in Florida. Your culinary adventure awaits!
Best pizza in the area. Consistently delicious! And love the poppers too! I usually order delivery and its always fast and hot!
Not a bad spot to get a slice to go. They're really quick. Pepperoni and Cheese slices are fresh. I'm a fan of their crust. Small take out shoppe with a couple tables outside to dine at.
Always order from here and tonight the pie was phenomenal! I got an extra large meat lovers. And they are not stingy with their toppings.Thanks guys!
I am not a big pizza consumer because it always upset my stomach, but recently I discovered a new place called New York New York Pizza and I wanted to try it after a long time and to my surprise, I liked it very much. Curious, I wanted to know what the difference was with the other pizzas, so I asked an employee and he told me that they only use olive oil and high quality products, they make it by hand and after two and a half hours, they throw away what they haven't sold and prepare it fresh again. I think this makes A BIG DIFFERENCE. I recommend it to everyone because I know it is VERY TRUSTED.
The pizza is like going back to NewYork. The best in Florida. Must have pizza when in Tampa. Service is outstanding
I love their pizza. The garlic knots are great. I don't know why more people don't go there!
Very good. I lived in NY before and pizza here are reminiscent of NYC pizza. Will def be back.